A dishwasher is an excellent part of the technical equipment of the kitchen. She eliminates the most unloved manual work of a housewife. At the same time, a good model works quietly, spends little water and energy, holds a large number of dishes. Therefore, a comparison of dishwashers will be useful and will help those who are thinking about buying such a functional and convenient device.
Very difficult question
Choosing a dishwasher is incredibly difficult. On the shelves there are a huge number of models from different manufacturers, each of which is able to drive crazy with various marketing tricks. There is an impressive array of features, each of which can play a decisive role when a dishwasher is bought.
In order not to arrange a vinaigrette from a list of properties, advantages and disadvantages, it is worth paying attention to a small detail of the market. On the shelves, in ratings, in consumer feedback collection systems, several brands are confidently leading.
Others are ready to offer interesting benefits, not being able to shine and occupy the pinnacles of leadership. And the narrowest segment is a dishwasher, a kind of “gray cardinal”, which is more expensive than its closest competitors, but offers an expanded set of functions, some of which make it very, very attractive.
Comparison of dishwashers (PM) will be carried out according to the following principle:
- The main direction is the rivalry between two recognized leaders, brands BOSCH and Siemens.
- As a "gray cardinal" will be the technique of Electrolux.
- As bright applicants, products of various brands of Europe will be considered, offering interesting functional technical solutions.
This line of rating building will make it possible to transparently show the evaluation criteria and easily understand the advantages and disadvantages of any PM model on the market.
Comparison will be carried out according to the following parameters:
- profitability in the context of water and energy consumption;
- a variety of dimensional solutions and types;
- technological performance in the context of control systems, security;
- noise level, vibration;
- amount of processed dishes.
An approximate cost estimate will be included in the rating for an honest comparison of the whole complex of parameters of a particular model.
Destroy myths and make comparisons
It’s impossible to say that Bosch and Siemens are competitors. These are trademarks belonging to one concern. Machines differ in technical indicators, engineering solutions, cost and level of technological perfection only because they are developed by separate design bureaus.
The list of countries where products are collected is also slightly different. In general, it is difficult to say with certainty whose models are better. It depends on the user's personal assessment, which is influenced by all factors and performance indicators of a particular product. But let's move on to comparing product lines according to a previously formed list of ratings.
Comparison of consumer appeal
Bosch, Siemens are very attractive to the consumer. Comparison of dishwashers is always in favor of these brands - with a large functional filling, German quality and other advantages, the manufacturer offers an attractive price. Another advantage of products of these brands is the presence of a comprehensive, equipped service network. The warranty also looks good. It is complete, that is, during the entire declared period, machine repair is free of charge.
Variety of performances
When deciding which dishwasher to choose, most people immediately plan where it will stand, how to fit into the interior and decor of the kitchen set. Bosch products are a clear favorite here. Among the variety of PMs, you can choose a model that is ideally suited for the size of the fit (if it comes to built-in appliances) or dimensions (if we talk about desktop or freestanding units).
Unlike Bosch dishwashers, Siemens products are a fairly standard, generally accepted size range. The same can be said about the products of the brand Electrolux. Ambitious candidates for leadership, companies from Europe, America (Ariston, Indesit, VEKO, Burning and others) offer even less. The size range is often poor, and the designs are standardized, expected, without interesting highlights.
Water consumption
If you compare dishwashers in terms of liquid flow, you can display approximate statistics for the class of devices.
- In the full-size PM sector, Siemens wins. Average consumption figures are from 6 to 14 liters, while Bosch has a minimum of 9 liters, Electrolux - 10, the best representatives of European brands - 8 liters.
- Bosch wins by a narrow margin in the sector of narrow models. The machines have a minimum consumption rate of 6 liters, Siemens shows 7, Electrolux and others - from 8 liters and above.
- Compact desktop and embedded machines show a wide variety of results. Here, the main competing brands are close to leadership, but lag behind Electrolux and some European products. So, a product from the Swedish brand will use 6.5-7 liters, Bosch will literally breathe in the back with 7-9 liters, and other brands show a consumption of 8 liters.
The conclusion from such statistics is simple. If the issue of paying for water is an acute issue and you have to wash a lot of dishes, Bosch confidently occupies the top of the rating in the sector of full-size units.
Energy consumption
In terms of electricity costs, a huge spread can be observed in the PM market. But the guideline for choosing is about 1 kW of average consumption per hour. Both Bosch dishwasher models and the nearest competitor, as well as a large number of models from European brands, have successfully met this parameter.
The electrolux is a little better: it is ready to offer consumption at the level of 0.7 kW, but most of the brand's products still show a consumption of about 0.91-0.95 kW. In a word, you can believe the logo of the economy class A, A +, AAA applied to the cars.
Manufacturability
The choice of a control system and adjustment tools can be decisive for people who prefer certain principles. Here the division is very striking.
- Bosch offers fairly balanced solutions. The number of switches is reduced to the average, the number of adjustments allows you to conveniently configure the modes. Indication clear, unobtrusive. There are many models, especially built-in ones, where all the controls are hidden from view.
- Siemens often suffers from the “Christmas tree complex”. Electronic control, large bright indicators, many buttons and knobs - so to speak about a huge number of models. With a brief overview of the possibilities, Siemens may be called technologically overloaded. However, the brand's reputation is not least built on the reliability of electronic solutions, so you should not worry about breakdowns of the dishwashers.
- The electrolux is ascetic. The number of regulators and switches is minimal, the indication on the floor is present in most models. Dishwashers look stylish, simple, you can set the desired mode with a couple of button presses.
Among other manufacturers, you can find a wide variety of technological solutions. It is difficult to speak clearly about their reliability. For example, LG, Ariston protect their electronic circuits from moisture. Other manufacturers use simple solutions - sealed touch panels and a minimum of chips. But Bosch, Siemens and Electrolux are uniquely leaders in terms of manufacturability and reliability.Machines of these brands are equipped with leakage protection of various levels, and it is up to the buyer to decide which one to choose.
Functional filling
Listing the functions that modern PM offers is a thankless task. There are just a huge number of them. Therefore, we indicate the main market trend:
- products from the two main competitors under consideration will offer about 6 modes, quick wash, intensive, as well as an economical mode of water consumption;
- many models from Electrolux will offer a special mode, which includes the use of biofertilizers, as well as washing in 30 minutes;
- European brands will please both functional and technical equipment:
- Ariston and Indesit will be pleased with Clic-Clac turbo-drying, preventing stains on the dishes (shelves are rearranged without being pulled out of the washing zone);
- Whirpool are able to boast of automatic determination of water quality and testing the cleanliness of dishes every 10 seconds;
- Asco know how to heat plates and effectively remove fat from them;
- Candy has a special Direct Spray mode when water hits the dishes under high pressure.
Briefly, one thing can be noted. If you choose a car that is convenient and functional, the products from the competitors in question will offer the perfect solution. If you need a twist, you can find a suitable model, but it will not be close to the market leaders.
What can i buy
Concluding the consideration of the question, which is better - Bosch or Siemens, one cannot but show with examples what can be bought on the market. Immediately worth noting: the models of these brands are approximately equally noisy, so the choice should be made, focusing on personal preferences. Examples will be given in pairs to compare the closest competitors from the market leaders in question.
Bosch SPV 40E10
A bright representative of the brand, a built-in model of a small width of 45 cm. There are 4 standard programs, half load, delayed start up to 9 hours, maximum water consumption of 11 liters and 9 sets of dishes that can be washed at the same time. Power consumption - only 0.8 kW.
The model is ideal for placement inside furniture - after closing the door, all controls and regulators are hidden from view.
Siemens SR 64E003
The closest competitor to the above model. Almost the same characteristics, with the exception of a slightly lower water consumption of 9 liters at maximum.
Feature of the model: it is intended only for installation in the kitchen, is sold without a front panel. It can be chosen as an option or installed independently ordered, appropriate furniture.
Bosch SPV 58M50
The model is medium in size. There is protection from children, 4 temperature settings, 5 standard programs, delayed start, you can wash up to 10 sets of dishes at the same time and spend only 9 liters of water and 0.9 kW of electricity.
The dishwasher allows the installation of a furniture frontal panel, sold complete with standard white. The model has hidden control and regulation systems, is equipped with a beam on the floor indication.
Siemens 66T090
Competitor to the above model. It is 20% more expensive in terms of average statistics, but it is ready to offer a half-load mode, more convenient integration (the door works by snapping after pressing and may not have a handle on the front furniture panel).
In addition, 6 programs are offered against a competitor’s 5 and slightly lower power consumption (0.8 versus 0.9 kW).
In the segment of freestanding machines, one can note a key feature of the assortment from the brands Bosch, Siemens. The latter has virtually no full-size models. Therefore, we consider two products of a compact class that are close in price and basic characteristics.
Bosch SPS 40E42
Convenient car with a good combination of price and functionality. It has 4 standard programs, 3 temperature settings, can process up to 9 sets of dishes and spend at the same time 9 liters of water and 0.78 kW of energy.
Half load mode is available, there is a delayed start functionality, full protection against leaks, noise - at an acceptable level, only 48 dB.
Siemens SR 24E202
The closest competitor, positioned as a more advanced and technologically advanced solution. A set of functions, programs, the number of dishes - the same.But in the model, the inverter motor of the supercharger of the sprinklers, the double rotating rocker of the upper box.
The disadvantages include some clear criteria and requirements that the manufacturer puts forward to the utilities of the house. In particular, when connected to a hot water supply, the water temperature cannot exceed 60 degrees, and the wiring must withstand a peak surge in consumption from the dishwasher of 2.5 kW.
In conclusion
When deciding which one to buy a dishwasher, the first thing is to go to the nearest service center for advice. Although the durability indicators of Bosch-Siemens products are at a high level and only 6% of consumers seek warranty repair (versus 15-20 for other brands in Europe and America), it will not hurt to assess the complexity and cost of eliminating problems.
In particular, for some Bosch models, the TEN system for heating water and the main control unit are a single set, so it changes completely. If one of the components fails after the warranty period, the repair will cost "a pretty penny." Similar irrational solutions exist for the models of the closest competitor. Therefore, getting advice from service engineers will not be superfluous.
 |  |  |  |  |
|
| Title | Bosch SPV 40E10 | Siemens SR 64E003 | Bosch SPV 58M50 | Bosch SPS 40E42 | Siemens SR 24E202 |
| Installation | fully integrated | fully integrated | fully integrated | freestanding | freestanding |
| Capacity | 9 sets | 9 sets | 10 sets | 9 sets | 9 sets |
| Water consumption | 11 l | 9 l | 9 l | 9 l | 9 l |
| Washing programs | intensive program for heavily soiled dishes, express program (fast cycle), economical program for lightly soiled dishes, pre-soak mode | express program (fast cycle), economical program for lightly soiled dishes, pre-soak mode, automatic programs | intensive program for heavily soiled dishes, express program (fast cycle), economical program for lightly soiled dishes, pre-soak mode, automatic programs | express program (fast cycle), economical program for lightly soiled dishes, pre-soak mode, automatic programs | express program (fast cycle), economical program for lightly soiled dishes, pre-soak mode, automatic programs |
| Price | from 23550 rub. | from 17000 rub. | from 57000 rub. | from 28500 rub. | from 28500 rub. |
Purely two brands in the top .. We need more variety, on a different budget, for example. From inexpensive here, Indesit would fit in well)
and you can also buy a hotpoint .. you really need to choose a model for yourself, as with any other equipment, but I think it will not disappoint anyone
It goes without saying that anyone at Hotpoint has excellent dishwashers, they are quiet, they wash the dirt well. For me they are generally one of the best.
Dear brands, I don’t even know. There would really be a few Indesites who would well dilute the picture, people have a different budget.
Still, I settled on a hotpoint. A friend advised and not in vain)
and I also chose a hotpoint. I'm sure of quality, because their washing machine has served me faithfully for 4 years, so the dishwasher will not let you down)
if you look precisely from the point of view of consumer attractiveness, then it is definitely indesit.here the price is acceptable, and the quality is reliable.